Apple - Time to clean our cloud!

Posted by petespeller - 24 April 2012 at 6:49pm - Comments
'Clean our cloud' poster in the window of Apple's London store
All rights reserved. Credit: Pete Speller/Greenpeace
Pasting up the 'Clean our cloud' banner at Apple's London store

Today, we went to Apple's flagship store in London to challenge them to clean up thier iCloud. Volunteers put up giant banners on the windows to catch the eyes of passers-by, as well as handing out hundreds of apples made from coal to customers at the Regent Street store.

Earlier this morning, volunteers questioned Apple staff at the Genius Bar about Apple's use of coal to power its iCloud.

Last week we launched the How Clean is Your Cloud? report that exposed the truth about how much coal goes into powering ‘the cloud’ – the giant data centres that store and send the terabytes of pictures, emails, songs and streaming videos we enjoy every day.

Companies like Google, Facebook and Yahoo have shown how global IT companies can use clean, renewable energy to power the services we use - in fact, it was thanks to you that last year Facebook announced its goal of running on clean, renewable energy sources. While Apple has made some encouraging announcements recently, its data centres are still primarily powered by a 19th century technology - coal.

Apple needs to ditch coal power and switch on to clean renewable energy. As visionary Apple founder Steve Jobs famously said "...the ones who are crazy enough to think that they can change the world are the ones who do." It's time for Apple to live up to that spirit.

Tell Apple CEO Tim Cook to clean our cloud!

I am shocked by how Greenpeace has done some of this campaign. I totally support the campaign in general, but in many ways the email-petition that was just sent out seems to be advertising Apple inc. as much as pointing out what needs to change. I like satirical adverts, and felt that Greenpeace's "kit-kat" one some time ago (about palm oil) was both good and effective.

However, this one had unnecessary advertising on behalf of the company:
 "Apple is a leader when it comes to innovative technology. While their products are cutting edge..."
"...our iPhotos..."
"...all the other things we love about Apple..."
"1. It's innovative: Apple is the most cutting-edge company..."
"These aren't evil companies. Their executives care about the world their children will inherit, just like we do."
The actual video itself made out that iCloud is something unique, whereas it isn't as there many other alternatives, including some which already use green energy.

Not only do I dislike advertisement, particularly from an organisation  that I like such as Greenpeace, but some of it just isn't true. Claims to be the most cutting-edge company are what I expect only from companies themselves, and it is an image that Apple inc. spends a lot of money on pushing, but regardless of weather the author of the article may have a preference for some of their products over those made by others, it is a very strong and unsubstantiated statement. Using "our" and "we love" is also an advertising approach, as it makes me feel like the statements either do, or should, apply to me - again, it is a personal preference to what operating system or music player you like best, and I dislike attempts to co-opt me to a belief that I don't hold.

Finally, and for me most importantly, claims that Steve Jobs was a visionary, or describing Apple as if they are not unethical are untrue. I'm not sure that these wider questions should be discussed by Greenpeace, as they are not relevant, but if do you should point out that they are unethical in many areas. This includes environmental damage as well as quite famously extremely bad working conditions, with high suicide rates and cases of child labour. Other issues can be read about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Apple#Labor_practices and https://www.facebook.com/AppleWatchGlobal . And lets face it, Steve Jobs did not set up apple for philanthropic reasons. I definitely thin this is an important campaign, I am just unsure as to how Greenpeace advertising on behalf of Apple Inc. will further it.

Your blog is design in beautiful way. I got many information by your blog which are so useful for us. You should make this type of blog continue. <a href="http://www.concreteartfx.com/">Concrete Resurfacing</a>

Your blog is design in beautiful way. I got many information by your blog which are so useful for us. You should make this type of blog continue. <a title="Concrete Resurfacing" href="http://www.concreteartfx.com/">Concrete Resurfacing</a>

Follow Greenpeace UK