Analysis
Guest post

Comment: Budget briefing - three ways the government is helping coal

Dr Jimmy Aldridge
Dr Jimmy Aldridge is a coal campaigner at Greenpeace
License: All rights reserved. Credit: Greenpeace

An older version of this article originally appeared on Left Foot Forward 

At the end of 2013 the government voted down an amendment to the energy bill that would have placed a limit on the carbon emissions from our oldest, dirtiest coal-fired power stations. Their argument for doing this was that other measures were making the economics of coal unattractive which was naturally pushing coal off the system.

However, as the graph below shows, generation from coal has been increasing. In 2012 44 per cent of electricity was generated coal – a 30 per cent increase on the previous year and it fell only slightly last year despite two major plants coming offline. Coal is not going away but has become our largest source of power.

As DECC noted in it's latest assessment "The contribution of coal to the UKs electricity mix remains high compared to recent years (between 2009-2011 coal provided around 30 per cent of the UK’s electricity generation)." 

From a climate perspective, this is a problem.

Coal is the most carbon intensive fuel used in the generation of electricity. It produces twice the carbon pollution of gas, and far above that of nuclear and renewables.

As the prime minister’s climate advisers have said repeatedly, any realistic attempt at decarbonising our power system must spell the end of coal-combustion unless emissions are captured through carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology.

Energydesk UK coal series:

Energy bill loophole allows return of King coal
Why is Europe burning more coal?
The takeover of coal: 4 charts on UK power generation
UK coal plants cause 1,600 premature deaths
Who owns Europe's coal? 

And it’s not just the impact on climate change; the Health and Environment Alliance – a network of health groups including London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine and Chartered Institute for Environmental Healthreported that British coal plants cause 1,600 premature deaths, 68,000 additional days of medication, and 363,266 working days lost each year.

The government have stated they “want, through the combined effect of all the measures in this (Energy) Bill, to create the conditions for an orderly, cost-effective transition away from high-carbon coal through investment in lower carbon alternatives”.  But this doesn’t ring true in practice. Rather than squeezing coal generators they are making things far easier for plants to stay open into the 2020’s and beyond.

Removal of the carbon price floor

One way in which they may help coal is if they remove or freeze the carbon price floor, as has been widely rumoured. Although this is an inefficient policy that has been criticised by industry groupsconsumer groups, and even green groups, without it the economics of coal are substantially improved.

If Parliament had known when the Energy Bill was being debated that the government was planning to remove this measure they may have seen the weaknesses in the government’s arguments and voted to include an explicit cap on coal plant emissions. The decision has certainly come very soon after the Energy Act received assent and MPs and Peers would be justified in feeling they had been voting with incomplete information.

Capacity market

Another way the government could help old coal stations is through the capacity market. This provides payments to generators to ensure there is sufficient capacity on the electricity system in the future to stop the lights going out. In the case of coal generators, these unexpected payments could help fund upgrades to their aging plants so they can meet EU directives on air pollution.

These upgrades will not reduce carbon emissions and they effectively extend the length of time coal plants can continue to operate. Whether the hand-outs from the capacity market are directly linked to these upgrades or not, they certainly help coal generators to keep generating high-carbon power.

A false sense of security

The motivation for smoothing the way for old coal probably stems from concerns that the lights could go out without it. But extending the lives of coal plants, which are cheap to run, deters investment in new capacity, including the gas plants the government wants brought forward. With the increased likelihood of the UK retaining a lot of coal in the mix, gas generators will feel their investments are higher risk.

In turn this means the government will have to provide larger subsidies to potential gas generators to incentivise investment and this will ultimately be paid for by consumers.

So although the extension of coal creates breathing space in the short-term, in the long-term it means higher costs to consumers and far higher emissions.

The government say they are committed to decarbonisation and that they want to move away from coal. But in reality their policies are improving the economics of coal and undermining the transition to a low-carbon system.

If George Osborne freezes the carbon price floor in his budget this month without introducing other measures to limit emissions, it will be a clear sign that the government are backing old coal at the cost of action on climate change. 

Comments Add new comment

, when Seneca's bowl and water (and possibly goldfish) were replaced by a flat-bottom, convex glass sphere that was laid on top of the reading material, becoming in effect the first magnifying glass and enabling the Sherlock
Holmes of medieval Italy to gather numerous clues to solve crimes.
The shapes of designs also have meanings and symbolism such as the
elephant with wealth and luck. Color television sets emit more EMF than do black and white sets, yet even the black and white TVs have been associated with 2.

Not only must you be able to identify Arowana diseases,
you must know how to treat them swiftly and safely. Aim to
become familiar with at least two drugs within each group.
Eczema is a general term for many types of skin inflammation (dermatitis).

Lorelei casts love spells during readings, done at Crow Haven Corner in Salem MA or over the phone.
The point in your left hand is to be directed towards your arm.
The sapphire has been linked with faith and purity, as well
as foresight.

Something to cool off in handily might be a great addition to the garden plan. When somebody mentions grow tents
an awful of people have no idea what is meant.
Subsequently, as the environment is perfected, the growing conditions are ideal for the plants, meaning
efficiency and healthier, faster yields.

The custom of Missoni is what can make them so exclusive in their apparel.
The importance of acupuncture is to perform the same function of herbs by stimulating
the movement of qi in the channels of which enhances the
function of organs in fighting against the over
growth fungus naturally and maintains the optimal healthy by
preventing the reoccurring of the diseases. The best treatment
for ick is to raise the water temperature to 85F, to add salt, and to remember
that you need to treat the whole tank and not just one fish that shows signs of this
parasite.

Obat Herbal Jus Kulit Manggis Penyakit Leukimia / Kanker Darah Kanker Darah di dalam bahasa Yunani leukos berarti putih; & aima berarti darah.obat kanker darah obat kanker usus

amazon Adalah Obat Alami Asam Urat Terpercaya obat asam urat

Any sale of health and wellness products is certainly estimated go over a
trillion dollars in the next two yrs. Here would definitely be a few
helpful how to earn amazing commissions thru marketing health and
wellness products. daily health trends 

UEFA Euro Cup 2012 is actually a famous foreign football tournament
situation hosted by way of Poland plus Ukraine, this tournament was
generated to get started 8th May 2012 but will last right until 1st
August 2012. In the following tournament you'll encounter 16 formidable
nations competing for any Euro Tumbler 2012. www.scorespro.com

thanks for informations, really good article
<b><a href="http://obatampuhatasipenyakit.blogspot.com/">Obat ampuh atasi penyakit</a>
<b><a href="http://obatampuhatasipenyakit.blogspot.com/2015/01/obat-herbal-bintik-merah-pada-kulit-bayi.html">Obat Bintik Merah Pada Kulit Bayi/<a>

Thank you for the very interesting information. I’m glad that you simply shared this helpful information with us. http://goo.gl/v1IwkY

Another way the government could help old coal stations is through the capacity market. Equally plant based as well as substance adult men health supplements can be purchased in market to aid individuals clearing away these kind of disorders. 
http://www.trillodesign.com/menadvice/

Subsequently, as the environment is perfected, the growing conditions are ideal for the plants, meaning - <a href="http://www.kaffahmedia.com">jasa seo murah bergaransi halaman 1 google</a>

Providing services from more than 5 years in high pagerank backlinks and we can say complete seo services.

http://www.organicseomarket.com

This is new information to us, the title of the article is very curious that people would be interested in reading, thanks for sharing of information on this subject
regards
http://www.andasumatra.com/

I wonder if Indonesian government will provide larger subsidies to potential gas generators to incentivise
investment and this will ultimately be paid for by consumers. Greeting from them team  of  http://www.jasa-seo.net/

 Equally plant based as well as substance adult men
health supplements can be purchased in market to aid individuals
clearing away these kind of disorders.

http://www.kaffahmedia.com

This is a great article who explain about government will provide larger subsidies to potential gas generators to incentivise.

Paket Wisata Bandung 

Don't worry about Wood Flooring of your home, you can choose Kroya Floors is International Quality like this post too

Something to cool off in handily might be a great addition to the garden plan. When somebody mentions grow tents
an awful of people have no idea what is meant.
Subsequently, as the environment is perfected, the growing conditions are ideal for the plants, meaning
efficiency and healthier, faster yields.

source: https://goo.gl/eRBmKj

dirtiest coal-fired power stations. Their argument for doing this was that other measures were making the economics of coal.

thank's : http://www.noperutbuncit.com

thank u for information three ways government helping coal instead tackling climate change

viem our company : http://www.jualobatpembesarklg.com

This information give me passion more and more http://sahabatarena.net

imagine how it could happen if it becomes an evil, it will have an impact pains http://wisatanabawi.com

I simply want to give you a huge thumbs up for the great info you have got here on this post. http://tokotasonline.org/

I'm impressed, I must say. Very rarely do I come across a blog that's both informative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you've hit the nail on the head. Your blog is important; the issue is something that not enough people are talking intelligently about.

http://bolalive77.com http://dewabet.asia http://vipbet88.com

dirtiest coal-fired power stations

 

http://casinoko.com | http://vegas88.asia 

This is new information to us, the title of the article is very curious that people would be interested in reading

http://dwlive88.com | http://bgselalu.com

On the other hand, it may be possible to secure a firm card through the identical financial corporations that present you with your personalized cards.

192.168.l.l192.168.l.254

Great work..looking for affordable and trusted hosting?come and visit.

http://unovegas.com

http://tangkasvip.com

http://bolatangkas.asia

Great work..looking for affordable and trusted hosting?come and visit.

http://unovegas.com

http://tangkasvip.com

http://bolatangkas.asia

Great work..looking for affordable and trusted hosting?come and visit.

http://unovegas.com

http://tangkasvip.com

http://bolatangkas.asia

I am very happy and like this page because I want to know what are the highlights of the writing on this website . 

Thank you for making all of this outstanding work .

 

Give a billion thumbs to you

 

Very nice post!

http://www.daftarjudibola.biz/daftar-sbobet-asia

http://www.daftartogel.info

http://www.gamerzconnect.com

http://www.jkttogel.com

http://www.jktbet.com

 

http://bit.ly/1WLwGNn

 

http://durl.me/c6prn4

 

http://durl.kr/ccxfro

 

http://durl.kr/ccxfyk

This is a very good post. Just wonderful. Truly, I am amazed at what informative things you've told us today 

http://gamedominoqiuqiuqq.com | http://bandarcapsasusunonline.com

 seriously appreciate people like you! Take care!!;)!!visit my site and Play

http://rajabet365.net

http://indolapak303.com 

http://asikqq01.com 

 seriously appreciate people like you! Take care!!;)!!visit my site and Play

http://rajabet365.net

http://indolapak303.com 

http://asikqq01.com 

 seriously appreciate people like you! Take care!!;)!!visit my site and Play

http://rajabet365.net

http://indolapak303.com 

http://asikqq01.com 

The government has a budgets briefing for helping coal.
 
 http://goo.gl/q3FFwc

Packers and Movers Mumbai Charges #
http://www.movers5th.in/packers-and-movers-mumbai/
Packers and Movers Pune Charges #
http://www.movers5th.in/packers-and-movers-pune/

Packers and Movers Delhi Charges #
http://www.movers5th.in/packers-and-movers-delhi/ 
Packers and Movers Gurgaon Charges #
http://www.movers5th.in/packers-and-movers-gurgaon/

Packers and Movers Hyderabad Charges #
http://www.movers5th.in/packers-and-movers-hyderabad/
Packers and Movers Bangalore Charges #
http://www.movers5th.in/packers-and-movers-bangalore/

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.