Senegalese fishermen fight back against factory fishing

Posted by Alicia C - 27 January 2012 at 5:38pm - Comments
All rights reserved. Credit: Clement Tardif / Greenpeace
Senegalese fisherman join Greenpeace campaigners in defending fish stocks from industrial trawlers

In the run up to the Senegalese presidential elections, Youssou N’dour isn’t the only controversial show on the road. Last week, a caravan tour organised by the small-scale fishing sector and our colleagues in Greenpeace Africa, called on presidential candidates to take urgent action against foreign super trawlers.  

Fleets of giant fishing foreign trawlers that operate off the West African coastline are sucking up millions of tonnes of precious local resources. Some of these trawlers - many from Europe - are literally floating fish factories, capable of catching, processing and freezing 300 tonnes a day. This is having a devastating effect on millions of local fishermen who rely on health fish stocks to support their families and local communities.  

During the week-long caravan tour, an impressive 6,000 representatives of large fishing ports across the country expressed concerns about the plunder of their marine resources. Fishermen placed their hand-prints on large banner, reading "Your voice counts, make it heard now". They are urging the candidates to commit to ending fishing authorisations being issued to foreign vessels, and instead support the local fishery sector.

And while fishermen in West Africa may seem a world away from small-scale fishing communities in Europe, they share a common bond. Both small-scale fishermen in the UK and Senegal are struggling as a result of mismanagement by decision makers who favour the short term economic interests of the industrialised fishing fleets.

Over the last few years, with increased technology, fishing vessels have become larger and more ruthless in their fishing techniques. A good example is the Pelagic-Freezer Trawler Association (PFA) fleet, which includes vessels owned by Dutch, German and UK companies. They use sophisticated sonar equipment to track fish across large areas of the sea, and a pipe sucks fish from immense nets into the belly of the ship where a processing factory turns them into frozen blocks.

The PFA and other super trawlers now roam the global seas, hunting down our remaining fish stocks. West Africa isn’t their only target, the world’s largest trawlers now head south towards the edge of Antarctica in a scramble for whatever’s left.

And who’s funding this? We are. EU taxpayers’ money keeps factory fishing afloat. For example, the PFA received fuel tax exemptions of between €20.9 million and €78.2 million from 2006 to 2011.  Taxpayer’ cover 90 per cent of the payments required for the PFA to have the right to fish in West Africa. EU funds helped the PFA build or modernise nearly half its fleet.

If all subsidies were removed, calculations show that PFA’s average yearly profit of around €55 million would, at best case, drop to €7 million, and at worst case, result in a loss of 50.3 million.

The mess we are in now is a result of mismanagement under the broken EU Common Fisheries Policy (CFP). But the CFP is in the process of being reformed. This happens only once a decade, and may be our last chance to turn the tide on a policy that has failed our oceans and fishing communities from Scotland to Senegal.

Issa Diop, a fishermen from Mauritania who came to the UK last year for our African Voices tour, sums up the issue perfectly:

“Our message is to tell the world that overfishing is very serious. Why is it serious? Because big vessels destroy the seas. There are fewer and fewer fish as technology is advancing at a fast rate.  23 million people are dependent on the fish stocks in West Africa. If you continue to overexploit these fish stocks, 23 million people will suffer.”

Is Greenpeace doing anything to forge links between these Senegalese fishing communities and small-scale fishermen here in the UK? A global union of small fishing folk would be a good thing, I think. I'd love to see Greenpeace bringing the downtrodden workers of the world together to fight big, unsustainable business!

Alicia!

Fish4Ever has led the way (and being roundly ignored by Greenpeace UK but not by Greenpeace Australia or HQ in Holland) in terms of tuna sourcing.  One of the actions we took was to refuse to source from long distance foreign boats.  This was before you started your campaign on tuna, 3 or 4 years ago.  And it's because we immediately saw that the problem in international tuna and fishing generally is the impact of global industrialised demand; big boats scouring the seas for quick profits, working under shady access deals (and/or just catching illegally) - but also the big supermarkets and multi-national brand businesses that are always looking to find product at the cheapest possible price and excercise a quasi-monopoly stranglehold on business.   All of this means built in un-sustainability.  It's also a repeat of that old model of private gain at public cost.   The consequences: overfishing, catch of juveniles, by-catch of endangered species, IUU fishing and above all economic and social damage done to those who we felt had a natural right to fish their own waters, the local coastal communities. 

So we could either walk away because yellowfin is either overfished or close to being so (depending on who you believe and when the science is updated) or we could try to provide a better alternative, i.e. oppose those who are creating the problem and support those who are being damaged - the local artisan fishermen.  It's not business that's bad, it's bad business that's bad.  So we've been backing the EJF in their attempt to combat illegal fishing further down the coast of W Africa and we chose to source our yellowfin (total stocks overfished and/or maximum fished) from Senegal, but from two locally owned pole and line boats.  We know that Senegal is a long way from where juvenile fish are caught, and generally felt this was a best choice in a complex situation. 

I would really love to find more about what you are doing in Senegal and to get your take on what's going on there and was heartened by this report.  

Charles



 

Follow Greenpeace UK