Sustainable bouillabaisse today or jellyfish burgers tomorrow?

Posted by benet - 31 January 2008 at 1:12pm - Comments

Callum Roberts, John Sauven, Antonio Carluccio, Raymond Blanc & Tom Aikens at the launch of Seafood See Life

Callum Roberts, John Sauven, Antonio Carluccio, Raymond Blanc & Tom Aikens at last night's launch

Sustainable bouillabaisse today or jellyfish burgers tomorrow: a stark message from the celebrity chefs and marine experts at the launch of Greenpeace's latest initiative Seafood See Life at Old Billingsgate Fish Market in the heart of the City of London.

Now, many Greenpeace staffers have secret passions. The nuclear team, for example, are known to tap their feet to some pretty bland music. But for me, it's food. And not just any old food, but the best food; served in world-class restaurants. Clearly it is a passion I can only enjoy sparingly (it is an eye-wateringly expensive habit) so I make up for it by spending hours reading reviews of the latest eateries online.

Of course great food is closely tied up with the creativity of the chefs that cook it. Not all celebrity chefs merit praise for their actual cooking, but Raymond Blanc and Tom Aikens do. So it was with particular interest that I heard them speak to assembled journalists, food campaigners and fish suppliers last night.

Seafood See Life is the latest step in our campaign for sustainable fishing practices. We've worked with supermarkets to persuade them to sell more fish from sustainable sources but we also need to persuade food writers, restaurateurs and – of course – the actual consumers. Getting the endorsement of celebrity chefs is a great way to do that; and it is fantastic to have the support of chefs who are leaders in their field (with a total of three Michelin Stars between them). All those attending last night were asked to pledge to do their bit to protect our oceans, and many signed up on the spot.

Because it is serious. Professor Callum Roberts – author of the indispensable The Unnatural History of the Sea spoke about the destruction of fish stocks over the years: from days when it was possible to catch blue fin tuna in the North Sea and cod so big you couldn’t carry them (you can here his speech here). Today, as we know, fish stocks are in crisis. The oceans – such a rich source of life and biodiversity – are now being trawled so extensively that the sea bed could soon turn into the aquatic equivalent of a dust bowl. That's why Greenpeace is calling for 40 per cent of our oceans to be designated marine reserves - national parks at sea where no fishing takes place and marine life gets a chance to recover.

Raymond Blanc spoke passionately about the personal responsibility of everyone involved in food for bringing about this crisis – for too long we've enjoyed endless fish without caring where it came from. But now things were changing and chefs were aware of the damage we can do to our planet.

Tom Aikens talked about his personal journey . How he has learnt about sustainability issues while he launches a new fish and chip restaurant. It was a moving story and included his thoughts on the livelihoods of fishing communities.

Of course, no one is saying we must never fish – but we need to protect 40% of the world's oceans to give them space to recover while we fish with sustainable methods in the rest. If we did this then fish stocks will recover; fishermen will still have a trade; and foodies like me will be still be able to enjoy langoustines, salmon and sole.

Find out more about Seafood See Life

Is your seafood sustainable: consult our 'red list' to see what should be off your menu

I am a demi-vegetarian and eat fish, but i wouldnt DREAM of eating a poor helpless innocent little jellyfish. I feel really guilty for eating fish, and i certainly wouldnt eat a jellyfish. I am ashamed to think that greenpeace representatives are actually going along with the slaughter of the jellyfish. I say ''what the hell is your problem?! Are you DEMENTED? Or are you just STUPID??????'' I thought greenpeace was against the kull of fish, not FOR it. i am totally ashamed of all those people [in greenpeace] who think its alright. IT ISN'T!! Youre meant to be trying to stop fisherman, so why the bloody hell are you going along with all those ignorant b******s who think that because jellyfish arent the same as like cod and sardines and stuff, that they can kill tham. JELLYFISH ARENT FOR EATING!!! if people start eating jellyfish, they will become endangered like narwhals. [not that people [i hope] havent tried eating narwhals]

My friend thinks: Its disgusting and i would rather eat a person than a jellyfish.

... just for the record, no one was actually advocating eating jellyfish, ok? The point is that should have been made in the blog (and having re-read it I can see that this is not clearly explained, although it is made in a number of other places on our site) is that destructive fishing is wiping out species at the top if the aquatic food-chain (tuna, cod, sharks etc) so fast that, if unchecked, soon only lower species will remain - hence the 'jellyfish burger' reference - if we go on at this rate that will soon be the only seafood that's left to eat.

Sorry if the intended irony was wasted on you - we never for a moment imagined that anyone could take it seriously. Obviously we were mistaken!

I feel so stupid. I obviosly didnt read the article properly. [well i read it a couple of times]

i see what youre getting at. people arent literally eating the jellyfish. [i thought they were.]

i am so stupid.

Sorry about that. [ i am only a teenager.]

Please don't worry about it. As I said, the article could certainly have been worded more clearly - and I loved the passion with which you leaped to the defence of the jellyfish - that's the sort of commitment the environmental movement definitely needs - so long as we get our facts right of course!

At the mo i am still @ school, but what age do i have to be to get ''officially'' involved?????

I love the whales and the fish, and want to help them so that they dont die out!!!!

I am a veggie and am giving up eating the fish @ the mo. I have been veggie forever and so have never tasted meat and never will!!!

i now it maced me sick jellyfish for dinner anyone ??????????
yuck !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

don't kill the earth

Sorry i didnt mean to insult ya [if i did] in the 1st blog i sent!! I thought ya were eatin the jellyfish. [i got the wrong end of da stick!!!]

Thanks 4 bein so sweet about it!!! [i am demented and i no it!!]

Go Greenpeace!!!!

I think if explained properly most people would rather eat less fish than carry on eating as much as people do now and end up with gratin du man o' war as a starter. (propably wouldn't work due to the jellyfish epidermis breaking up when heated due to water loss) anyway hopefully this is the beggining of a bigger swing towards sustatinable fisheries by all.

p.s. I am not keen on the phrase (I am just a teenager) I am 17, 18 in march.

peace, Jethro Gauld.

JetG. rescue diver extraordinaire. (running london marathon to raise money for greenpeace)

when i said that, i was talkin about myself. I didnt mean ya. [ i am only 13.]Soz if it offended ya!!!!!

Anyway i think that people eatin fish is NOT good atall!!!! i am veggie and am givin up da fish @ da mo.

Go Greenpeace!!!!

I am a demi-vegetarian and eat fish, but i wouldnt DREAM of eating a poor helpless innocent little jellyfish. I feel really guilty for eating fish, and i certainly wouldnt eat a jellyfish. I am ashamed to think that greenpeace representatives are actually going along with the slaughter of the jellyfish. I say ''what the hell is your problem?! Are you DEMENTED? Or are you just STUPID??????'' I thought greenpeace was against the kull of fish, not FOR it. i am totally ashamed of all those people [in greenpeace] who think its alright. IT ISN'T!! Youre meant to be trying to stop fisherman, so why the bloody hell are you going along with all those ignorant b******s who think that because jellyfish arent the same as like cod and sardines and stuff, that they can kill tham. JELLYFISH ARENT FOR EATING!!! if people start eating jellyfish, they will become endangered like narwhals. [not that people [i hope] havent tried eating narwhals] My friend thinks: Its disgusting and i would rather eat a person than a jellyfish.

... just for the record, no one was actually advocating eating jellyfish, ok? The point is that should have been made in the blog (and having re-read it I can see that this is not clearly explained, although it is made in a number of other places on our site) is that destructive fishing is wiping out species at the top if the aquatic food-chain (tuna, cod, sharks etc) so fast that, if unchecked, soon only lower species will remain - hence the 'jellyfish burger' reference - if we go on at this rate that will soon be the only seafood that's left to eat. Sorry if the intended irony was wasted on you - we never for a moment imagined that anyone could take it seriously. Obviously we were mistaken!

I feel so stupid. I obviosly didnt read the article properly. [well i read it a couple of times] i see what youre getting at. people arent literally eating the jellyfish. [i thought they were.] i am so stupid. Sorry about that. [ i am only a teenager.]

Please don't worry about it. As I said, the article could certainly have been worded more clearly - and I loved the passion with which you leaped to the defence of the jellyfish - that's the sort of commitment the environmental movement definitely needs - so long as we get our facts right of course!

At the mo i am still @ school, but what age do i have to be to get ''officially'' involved????? I love the whales and the fish, and want to help them so that they dont die out!!!! I am a veggie and am giving up eating the fish @ the mo. I have been veggie forever and so have never tasted meat and never will!!!

i now it maced me sick jellyfish for dinner anyone ?????????? yuck !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! don't kill the earth

Sorry i didnt mean to insult ya [if i did] in the 1st blog i sent!! I thought ya were eatin the jellyfish. [i got the wrong end of da stick!!!] Thanks 4 bein so sweet about it!!! [i am demented and i no it!!] Go Greenpeace!!!!

I think if explained properly most people would rather eat less fish than carry on eating as much as people do now and end up with gratin du man o' war as a starter. (propably wouldn't work due to the jellyfish epidermis breaking up when heated due to water loss) anyway hopefully this is the beggining of a bigger swing towards sustatinable fisheries by all. p.s. I am not keen on the phrase (I am just a teenager) I am 17, 18 in march. peace, Jethro Gauld. JetG. rescue diver extraordinaire. (running london marathon to raise money for greenpeace)

when i said that, i was talkin about myself. I didnt mean ya. [ i am only 13.]Soz if it offended ya!!!!! Anyway i think that people eatin fish is NOT good atall!!!! i am veggie and am givin up da fish @ da mo. Go Greenpeace!!!!

Follow Greenpeace UK