What gives us more energy security? Deploying troops to secure gas pipelines, or building a renewable economy?
Since
before their conference in October the Conservative party have been raising fears of
energy blackouts in Britain. Greg Clark, Shadow energy
minister, even claimed in his party conference speech that 'there must be immediate action to keep the lights on' - a speech
which, for dramatic effect, began in a darkened room. The same language was
trotted out at a debate about gas security in Westminster we helped organise, when Charles
Hendry, Conservative Shadow Minister for Energy, raised the spectre of energy
blackouts. He
claimed
that during the recent cold spell Britain had been ‘down to three days
of gas storage' and had ‘reached the situation where we were at risk.'
What's
going on here? Well, the thinly veiled subtext behind the Tory line goes like
this: Britain is at the mercy of foreign
powers - in particular the Russians - who supply us with our gas. It's a pretty
strong challenge. But is it right?