Leaked document reveals government set to miss key wildlife pledge

Greenpeace warns of “dangerous gulf” between ministers’ promises and reality on the ground


The UK government has quietly abandoned efforts to meet a longstanding target to improve England’s top wildlife sites despite Theresa May’s high-profile commitment to enhance Britain’s natural environment, according to a leaked document seen by Unearthed.

The official document also warns that Natural England, the government’s nature regulator, is too stretched to prevent “further human-induced extinctions of known threatened species” and is also at high risk of failing on other conservation targets.

The revelations come on the day Environment Secretary Michael Gove is expected to deliver a high-profile speech at the Conservative Party Conference.

Gove’s department had a central government target, set by the Coalition government in 2011, to restore 50% of England’s sites of special scientific interest (SSSIs) by area to “favourable condition” by 2020.

But a leaked internal Natural England action plan shows the agency is actually working towards restoring just 38.7% of these nature sites to the top grade in the agency’s scale – a target just 0.07% higher than the status quo.

Sites of special scientific interest protect England’s most important areas for biodiversity, from the Lake District to the Pennines to Exmoor. Unearthed has found parts of all of these areas that were recorded as being in “unfavourable” condition when they were last assessed.

The strategy also warns of a “high” likelihood that “resources, and thus actions, are inadequate to meet the Biodiversity 2020 target to secure an overall improvement in the status of our wildlife and to prevent any further human-induced extinctions of known threatened species”.

Natural England’s budget has nearly halved in the past decade. In 2017/18 it was £112m, down from £200m in 2006/7, its chairman Andrew Sells told parliament in December.

Commenting on the document, Greenpeace UK executive director John Sauven said:

“This strategy is a monumental letdown for anyone who cares about the future of our countryside and wildlife. There’s a dangerous gulf opening up between what Theresa May promised and what her top nature watchdog is planning to deliver to improve the state of our environment. Natural England is not just on track to miss a crucial target for regenerating some of our best-loved nature sites, it’s also heading for failure on protecting threatened species from extinction. If the prime minister wants to turn her vision of a greener Britain into reality, we’re going to need proper funding for agencies on the ground, an Environment Act with legally-binding commitments, and a watchdog with the teeth to enforce it.”

The government has a statutory duty to “further the conservation and enhancement” of SSSIs, under the Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000.

The leaked plan, which was signed off by Defra, comes eight months after Theresa May launched the government’s 25 year environment plan, which pledged to ensure protected areas are “not only conserved but enhanced” and set a new target to bring 75% of SSSIs into favourable condition within the lifetime of the plan.

Three weeks ago, a parliamentary question from Caroline Lucas, co-leader of the Green party, revealed that almost half of England’s SSSIs have not been monitored in the last six years, as is required by national guidelines.


You can read the full story on Unearthed, Greenpeace’s investigative platform.

Contact: Greenpeace UK news team at press.uk@greenpeace.org, 020 7865 8255 or 07807 149439

What's next?